Recap: SN1-05, “Mary Pat Shelby”
Wednesday, May 28th, 2008
We’re taking a second look at “Mary Pat Shelby,” the fifth episode of Sports Night. Following up on the review, here’s a recap of the episode. Still to come: memorable lines from the episode.
Isaac’s got good news for Dana: Sports Night, their little #3 show, has scored a hit-making appearance by football player Christian Patrick. He’s coming to the studio, he’s sitting down for an interview, and if they promote the heck out of it, he’s going to bring tons of new viewers along with him. Dana breaks the good news to Dan, interrupting his musings on whether or not he should grow a goatee. Also getting word of the show’s big break is Natalie, who is Dana’s choice to go do a locker-room pre-interview with Patrick. Natalie’s pretty sure Jeremy, with his superior football knowledge, would be a better choice, but Dana wants Natalie and that’s that.
Of course, once they have promoted the heck out of it and there’s no turning back, Patrick’s lawyers issue some guidelines on what can and cannot be talked about. Foremost on the latter list is Mary Pat Shelby, the girlfriend Patrick is accused of beating up. No, no questions about that, not even the merest mention. Casey tells Dana she’s doing a big thing badly, and getting played, and Dana doesn’t disagree — but the fact is, the show needs the interview and the viewers and the producer will do anything to make it work. Casey tries to engage Dan in arguing the decision, but as it happens, this is Dan’s day off from caring about ethical violations.
When Natalie comes back from the Patrick pre-interview, she runs into Jeremy in an editing room and he notices a bruise on her wrist. She has some story about catching it in a car door and insists it’s nothing, but Jeremy points out that it looks exactly like the Indian burn his sister gave him when they were kids. Later, in a rundown meeting that has mostly to do with the lighting problems Dan’s goatee might cause, Isaac bursts in with news of reports from the Meadowlands that, in an empty locker room, Christian Patrick was seen exposing himself to a women. He might have done more, Isaac says, because the witness saw him grab the woman’s arm. Jeremy asks, frantically, whether it might have been her wrist, then runs out of the room. It only takes Casey a few seconds to realize what this means: The woman was Natalie.
The gang rallies around Natalie, who claims it was no big deal. Isaac says they’ll get a car to take her home so she doesn’t have to see Patrick in the studio, but she wants to stay and do her job, and Isaac reluctantly agrees. Dana, meanwhile, sees that what happened to Natalie makes this a whole new ballgame. First, she’s telling Casey and Dan that the show is going to be the first to report on what happened in the locker room, because it’s their story and because Natalie deserves to have her story told. Dan points out that, actually, Natalie doesn’t seem all that interested in having her story told, and that sets Dana off into another whole new ballgame: She makes a deal with Patrick’s lawyers that Natalie will not press charges if the interview is opened to include questions about Mary Pat Shelby. They agree, but Dana and Isaac start to look like maybe this isn’t such a victory.
Jeremy tries to comfort Natalie, but she’s noticed all the conversations going on outside the room she’s in, and all the phones ringing, and she knows just how bad it can get for a female journalist who complains about what goes on in a locker room. Afterward, Jeremy runs into Christian Patrick in the hallway, and tells him that if he ever touches Natalie again, Jeremy’s going to have him killed. Patrick just laughs it off, and says that judging by the look on Natalie’s face, she was pretty impressed with him.
Casey talks to an increasingly uncertain Dana, who admits that she sent Natalie into the locker room in the hope that it might provoke Patrick. Casey assures her that she’ll do the right thing. Meanwhile, Dan is saying something along the same lines to Natalie, assuring her that no matter what happens, she has friends, and this is what friends suit up for.
And so, it turns out to be a bad day for Christian Patrick, and a not-so-great day for Sports Night’s bottom line. Ethics, though, are on an upswing: Dana cancels the interview and kicks Patrick and his lawyers out of her studio, and Natalie tells Patrick that she’s going to press charges against him, turning both of their lives upside down.
Photo by Terri Mauro
As a follow-up to the
We’re taking a second look at “Intellectual Property,” the fourth episode of Sports Night. Following up on the
We’re taking a second look at “The Hungry and the Hunted,” the second episode of Sports Night. Following up on the 
We’re taking a second look at “The Apology,” the second episode of Sports Night. Following up on the 
We’re taking a second look at “Pilot,” the very first episode of Sports Night. Following up on the 




We’re taking a second look at “K&R Part II,” the twentieth episode of Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip. Following up on the
As a follow-up to the recap of